
A Newsweek opinion article calls for resident choice in senior living. Learn what it means for learning, purpose and claims about cognitive health.

On October 29, 2026, Newsweek published an opinion article arguing that senior living should give residents more control over daily life. Its author is Allison Combs, chief marketing officer at National Lutheran Communities & Services.
Combs argues that senior living should support independence and relationships alongside housing and care. Her case also makes room for learning and contribution. Residents should have a role in deciding how they spend their time rather than simply receiving a schedule created for them.
That role could include choosing speakers or helping shape educational programs. Residents might also lead groups built around shared interests. In Combs’s account, the point is not just to provide activities but to give people influence over what those activities become.
This shifts the question from how much programming a community offers to whose interests it reflects. A full calendar and a meaningful role in shaping that calendar are different things. The article asks senior-living providers to pay attention to both.
To describe changing retirement expectations, Newsweek cites Fidelity Investments’ 2026 State of Retirement Planning Study:
Combs connects these expectations with a broader argument about agency. Retirement need not mean stepping away from every role that involves judgment or responsibility. Her proposed response is to make space for residents to continue shaping their surroundings and contributing to community life.
Housing capacity forms another part of the article’s backdrop. Newsweek cites NIC MAP projections of approximately 576,000 additional senior-housing units by 2030 and more than one million by 2035 to maintain occupancy near 90%.
For this discussion, the editorial distinction is between providing enough housing and providing a setting people can help direct. The number of available homes does not answer who chooses the learning topics or whose ideas become community programs.
A separate Los Angeles Times report offers a concrete example. At The Leonard on Beverly, resident Ferne Walpert founded a program connecting residents in independent and assisted living with neighbors in memory support. She said she wanted to remain “challenged and relevant.”
The activities included art and walks alongside reading aloud. The program connected people across care settings while giving a resident a role in creating that opportunity.
The detail worth noticing is who originated the idea. Walpert was not described only as someone attending an activity. She was contributing an idea that involved other residents and gave her an active part in community life.
That example gives Combs’s argument a practical shape. Resident involvement can mean more than selecting from options already on offer. It can also mean helping decide what belongs on the calendar in the first place.
For senior-living leaders, the useful question is whether residents have a route from an interest to a shared activity. For residents, it is whether their knowledge and preferences have somewhere to go. Both questions keep the focus on participation in decisions rather than attendance alone.
For someone assessing a community today, the practical use of this argument is to look beyond the activity list. Ask how programs take shape and what role residents have in that process. The reporting supports several questions about everyday fit.
Ask how residents influence speaker choices and educational programming. A list of talks shows what is available. Asking how those topics were chosen gets closer to whether the program reflects the people who live there.
The same question applies to interest groups. The relevant issue is whether residents’ actual interests have a place in community life rather than whether every possible topic appears on a brochure.
Combs identifies resident-led interest groups as one way to support engagement. The Los Angeles Times example shows a resident creating a program that connected neighbors across care settings.
A useful question is what happens when someone brings an idea forward. Is there a way to suggest a speaker or help shape a group? Asking for an example can make the answer more concrete than a broad statement about resident involvement.
Choosing a speaker and leading an interest group represent different levels of involvement. Both appear in Combs’s argument. Looking for these different roles helps distinguish opportunities to participate from opportunities to influence.
The point is to understand what is available. A person may be interested in helping organize something or may prefer joining an activity someone else has arranged.
The reporting suggests asking about opportunities for learning and connection together. It also directs attention toward residents’ own priorities rather than a single model of an active retirement.
These questions sit alongside broader topics in FitBrainLab’s resources on directing daily life after retirement and building meaning beyond a work role. The aim is to describe the kind of daily life a person values before judging how well a community fits it.
The sources support a discussion about choice and engagement. They do not establish that resident-led programs improve memory or prevent dementia.
A 2026 study published in the Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health provides relevant cognitive-health context. It pooled five national longitudinal surveys with 57,793 participants and found that social-activity participation was associated with higher cognitive-function scores. Its observational design does not establish that participation caused those differences.
That finding should remain separate from the examples of resident leadership. The Los Angeles Times account illustrates what one resident created. It is not evidence that every resident-led program produces the same experience or outcome.
The Newsweek piece also needs to be read for what it is: an opinion article by a senior-living industry executive. It is not an independent evaluation of senior-living programs. Combs’s stated professional affiliation matters when weighing her recommendations.
The retirement survey figures have a separate boundary. They describe surveyed Americans rather than adults over 60 specifically. Newsweek does not provide the survey’s methodology or sample details, so the figures should not stand in for the preferences of all older adults or retirees.
The housing projections require their own distinction. NIC’s outlook describes a cumulative gap between required and actual deliveries under its model. These are not guaranteed construction totals or predictions of demand in every locality.
Finally, resident choice must include the choice not to organize or attend. Combs acknowledges differences in priorities and abilities alongside support needs. Independence can coexist with assistance; a busy schedule is not a test that every resident must pass.
The practical boundary is clear: use questions about programming to assess fit. Personal concerns about memory or cognitive change belong in a discussion with a qualified healthcare professional rather than being settled by an activity calendar.
The lasting value of this discussion is a wider view of what deserves attention in later life. Combs puts residents’ decisions and contributions into a conversation often framed around housing and care. The resident-led example makes that argument concrete without settling the scientific questions about cognition.
For long-term cognitive-health reporting, two questions deserve room: what research measures and what people want their lives to contain. Cognitive-function scores address one part of that discussion. Learning interests and meaningful roles address another.
A worthwhile direction for senior living is to take both seriously. Residents can be part of defining a community’s intellectual and social life rather than being treated only as recipients of services. That is a reason to ask better questions about choice and purpose while keeping health claims tied to evidence.
Cognitive-function scores give this discussion a measurable reference point, while FitBrainLab explains the evidence connecting engagement and brain aging for adults 60+. When retirement leaves gaps in structure or learning opportunities, its editorial coverage helps readers understand research on purposeful living and mental engagement without turning a community activity into a promise about future health.
Follow FitBrainLab for research-led insights on memory, focus, brain aging, nutrition and mental fitness after 60. Stay connected for new articles, practical guidance and ideas for a sharper, more engaged life.



Build habits that support memory, focus and a curious, connected life.
Read the Blog